Bath Planet vs Bath Fitter vs Rebath - In-depth Comparison

Bath Planet vs Bath Fitter vs Rebath: In-depth Comparison

When it comes to upgrading your bathroom, choosing the right remodeling service can feel overwhelming. With options like Bath Planet, Bath Fitter, and Rebath, homeowners are often left wondering: Which company will give me the results I want within my budget and timeframe? Each of these brands has its specialty, unique features, and pricing structure, making it essential to understand what each one offers.

This article dives deep into Bath Planet, Bath Fitter, and Rebath, comparing their strengths, weaknesses, and ideal use cases to help you make the best decision for your home.

Learn more: Kitchen Lighting Mistakes to Avoid for a Well-Lit Space

Why Bathroom Remodels are Worth the Investment?

Bathroom remodeling has grown in popularity over recent years, and for good reason. Bathrooms are more than functional spaces; they’re a retreat for relaxation, a showcase for style, and one of the most important rooms in terms of home value. A well-done remodel can dramatically increase the comfort and appeal of a bathroom while boosting property value. Choosing a service that aligns with your vision, budget, and needs is essential to achieving a result that’s both satisfying and financially sound.

Introduction to Bath Planet, Bath Fitter, and Rebath

Before we dive into comparisons, let’s get a snapshot of each brand.

  • Bath Planet was founded in 1999, making it the youngest of the three. It’s known for specializing in “one-day” bathroom remodels that focus on shower-to-tub conversions and other quick transformations. The brand prides itself on its use of high-quality materials and its ability to modernize bathrooms without the long wait time that traditional remodels often require.
  • Bath Fitter has been around since 1984 and is best known for its custom acrylic bathtub and shower liners, which are designed to fit over existing units for quick and convenient updates. Bath Fitter emphasizes customization within its specialty and has a reputation for installing high-quality, durable acrylic solutions that make bathrooms look brand new without extensive demolition.
  • Rebath, the oldest of the three, was founded in 1978 and offers the most comprehensive range of remodeling services. Unlike Bath Planet and Bath Fitter, Rebath specializes in full-scale remodels, which means they go beyond just tubs and showers. From flooring to fixtures, Rebath can completely overhaul your bathroom, though the more extensive remodeling comes with a longer installation timeline and higher costs.

Comparing Services: What Does Each Brand Offer?

When comparing these brands, it’s essential to understand the scope of work each one typically handles.

  • Bath Planet’s Services: Bath Planet’s focus is on efficiency and transformation. The company offers a variety of services, with an emphasis on conversions—like switching from a bathtub to a walk-in shower or vice versa. These conversions typically don’t require removing walls or altering plumbing significantly, which is why the brand is known for completing projects in just one day. Bath Planet uses durable materials designed to last while providing homeowners with style options, including various finishes and colors.
  • Bath Fitter’s Services: Bath Fitter is ideal for homeowners who want a fresh look for their bathrooms without a complete overhaul. The company customizes acrylic liners to fit perfectly over your existing tub or shower, creating a seamless, waterproof result. This approach is less invasive than other remodeling methods, which reduces both the time and cost involved. Bath Fitter is known for its precision manufacturing and installation process, ensuring that the liner fits exactly, leaving no room for leaks or gaps.
  • Rebath’s Services: If you’re looking for a top-to-bottom bathroom remodel, Rebath is the service to consider. Unlike Bath Planet and Bath Fitter, Rebath offers comprehensive remodeling options that include wall replacements, new fixtures, and flooring in addition to bath and shower installations. They work with high-quality materials like ABS and solid surface polymers, making them ideal for homeowners who want durable, stylish, and lasting results. While Rebath projects can take more than a day, the results are often more extensive and personalized.

Installation Process: What to Expect

Each brand’s installation process is unique, affecting the time and labor involved.

  • Bath Planet Installation: Bath Planet’s “one-day installation” promise is ideal for those seeking a fast, effective remodel. The company uses custom-fit solutions that minimize demolition and reduce labor time. Their technicians handle everything from measuring to installing new bath or shower units. By focusing on conversions and surface replacements, Bath Planet can deliver a full transformation without the wait, typically completing projects within a day.
  • Bath Fitter Installation: Bath Fitter’s installation is also quick, often taking only a day. Since they use custom acrylic liners that fit over existing fixtures, the process is non-invasive. Bath Fitter prides itself on precision, with each liner being specifically measured and crafted for each bathroom. This tailored approach means that once the acrylic is in place, the bathroom looks seamless and brand new, with no visible signs of an overlay.
  • Rebath Installation: For Rebath, the installation timeline varies based on the project’s scope. Because Rebath often handles more comprehensive remodels, installation can take a few days or even weeks, depending on the complexity. Rebath professionals manage everything from demolition to the installation of flooring, wall surrounds, and fixtures. While it’s a more time-intensive process, the result is a completely refreshed and personalized bathroom space.

Cost Comparison: Finding the Right Price Point

Budget is often a key factor in choosing a bathroom remodeling service. Each brand’s costs differ based on the complexity of the project, the materials used, and the level of customization.

  • Bath Planet Costs: Bath Planet is generally considered a budget-friendly option for homeowners seeking quick upgrades. The simple tub or shower conversions can range from $1,500 to $7,000, depending on the materials and custom options. The brand’s ability to complete remodels in a day helps reduce labor costs, making it a good choice for budget-conscious homeowners.
  • Bath Fitter Costs: Bath Fitter’s costs are fairly consistent because of their unique liner system. Basic installations typically range from $1,000 to $2,500, with higher-end options costing up to $7,000, depending on customization and materials. Bath Fitter’s durable acrylic liners are designed to last, making them a solid investment for those seeking a mid-range bathroom makeover without extensive remodeling.
  • Rebath Costs: Rebath is generally the most expensive of the three, with prices often exceeding $10,000 for a full bathroom remodel. Because Rebath offers everything from wall replacements to new fixtures, the cost can vary widely based on individual project needs. While Rebath is more of an investment, it’s often worth it for homeowners who want a high-quality, comprehensive remodel that will last for decades.

Materials and Quality

Each of these brands is known for using high-quality materials, though the type of material differs across companies.

  • Bath Planet Materials: Bath Planet uses durable, non-porous materials that resist mold and mildew, making them easy to maintain. These materials are designed to mimic the look of high-end surfaces without the cost or upkeep, and they come in a variety of finishes to match any style.
  • Bath Fitter Materials: Bath Fitter is known for its strong, custom-made acrylic liners, which are designed to last for many years. The liners are mold-resistant, easy to clean, and come in a range of finishes. The precision-fit design ensures that the liner remains in place, looking new for years to come.
  • Rebath Materials: Rebath’s material selection is broader, given its focus on full remodels. They offer everything from ABS polymer to solid surfaces and even some tile options. Rebath’s materials are chosen for their durability and resistance to wear and tear, making them ideal for homeowners who want a lasting solution.

Pros and Cons: Which Brand is Right for You?

Now let’s explore some pros and cons of each option:

  • Bath Planet: Bath Planet is best for those who want a quick, efficient remodel at an affordable price. However, because they focus on surface replacements and conversions, they’re not ideal for those wanting a full remodel.
  • Bath Fitter: Bath Fitter is perfect for homeowners who want a fresh look without the hassle of demolition. While limited to acrylic liners, Bath Fitter’s quality and customization options make it a popular choice.
  • Rebath: Rebath is the ideal choice for those looking for a comprehensive remodel. Though it’s more expensive, the investment can be worthwhile for homeowners wanting a brand-new bathroom with lasting materials.

Making the Final Decision

In choosing between Bath Planet, Bath Fitter, and Rebath, consider your budget, the scope of your remodel, and your timeline. If you’re looking for a quick and affordable transformation, Bath Planet or Bath Fitter may be the way to go. However, if you want a complete remodel that reimagines your bathroom from top to bottom, Rebath offers comprehensive services to bring your vision to life. With this knowledge, you can confidently choose a remodeling service that best suits your needs and preferences.

Scroll to Top