Bathrooms are one of the most used rooms in our homes. We all know that if we use something excessively it gets damaged, outdated and expires in very less time. Similarly, our bathrooms also get damaged, outdated and sometimes unsafe to use with time.
When it comes time for a bathroom remodel, there are three main choices: Rebath, Bath Fitter, and Bath Planet. All three companies offer similar services, but some key differences can make one company a better choice than the others.
Learn more: Kitchen Lighting Mistakes to Avoid for a Well-Lit Space
Why Bathroom Remodels are Worth the Investment?
Bathroom remodeling has grown in popularity over recent years, and for good reason. Bathrooms are more than functional spaces; they’re a retreat for relaxation, a showcase for style, and one of the most important rooms in terms of home value. A well-done remodel can dramatically increase the comfort and appeal of a bathroom while boosting property value. Choosing a service that aligns with your vision, budget, and needs is essential to achieving a result that’s both satisfying and financially sound.
Bath Planet vs Bath Fitter vs Rebath
Although Rebath, Bath Fitter, and Bath Planet offer almost similar services, but still some key differences exist that make one company a better choice than the others. Let’s compare them in detail to find out which one aligns with your needs, requirements, and budget.
Introduction to Bath Planet, Bath Fitter, and Rebath
Before we dive into comparisons, let’s get a snapshot of each brand.
Bath Planet
Bath Fitter began in 1984 and is famous for its custom acrylic tub and shower liners. These liners are made to fit over your current tub or shower, so the update is fast and clean. Bath Fitter is known for strong, durable acrylic products that make your bathroom look new without tearing anything out.
Bath Fitter
Bath Fitter is based in Springfield, Tennessee. Founded in 1984. They are known for their custom acrylic tub and shower liners. They use the PermaFit™ method to make their liners in such a way that they exactly fit over your current tub or shower, so the update is fast and clean.
Rebath
Re-Bath is the oldest one among the three and founded in 1978. The main difference it has from Bath Futter and Bath Planet is that ReBath offers full bathroom remodel rather than simple upgrade. They can redo everything: the tub, shower, walls, flooring, fixtures, and more. Their remodels take longer and cost more, but they give you a fully redesigned and upgraded bathroom.
Comparing Services and Option Provided by Bath Planet, Bath Fitter, and Rebath
When comparing these brands, it’s essential to understand the scope of work each one typically handles.
Bath Planet’s Options and Services
Bath Planet offers fast and efficient bathroom makeovers that don’t require huge demolition or long waiting time. They can turn an old bathtub into a modern shower or convert a shower back into a tub in just one day.
They use long-lasting acrylic tubs, showers, and wall systems that are built to fit into your existing bathroom so you get a fresh new look without tearing down walls or redoing major plumbing. There are lots of style and color options, so you can pick a design that matches your taste when they remodel.
Because of their quick process and use of durable materials, Bath Planet’s service is ideal for people who want a fresh, clean, modern bathroom without the mess, hassle, or long wait of a full renovation.
Bath Fitter’s Options and Services
Bath Fitter helps you upgrade your bathtub or shower. Bath fitters provide upgrades for both bathtubs and showers. For each type, they provide custom-fit liners or replacements that go over your existing tub or shower.
Their signature system is called PermaFit™. It is their special fitting method in which Bath Fitter measures your old tub or shower very carefully. They make a new acrylic tub or shower liner that has the same dimensions as your older one. Then they place this new liner on top of your old tub or shower. Consequently, there is no demolition, no mess and much less hassle compared to a full bathroom rebuild.
You can customize the new bath or shower to match your taste or home décor.
If you prefer, Bath Fitter can also convert a bathtub into a shower or create a walk-in / easy-access shower which can be helpful especially for older adults and people with joint and muscle disorders.
Their installation process is surprisingly quick: in many cases, they can finish the upgrade in one day so you don’t have to deal with long construction or being without a bath/shower for days.
Their tubs and showers are usually made with high-gloss acrylic and tight water-proof seals therefore their maintenance is easy. Bath Fitter offers safe and accessible bath/shower options like low-threshold walk-in showers, built-in seats, and grab bars making bathing easier and safer.
Moreover, Bath Fitter install comes backed with a lifetime warranty (or at least a long-term guarantee), which gives homeowners extra confidence and long-term peace of mind.
Rebath’s Options and Services
Re-Bath offers full bathroom remodeling rather than mere tubs or showers so you can transform your entire bathroom from worn out one to fresh and modern. If you don’t need a complete remodel, Re-Bath also gives services to partially upgrade your bath like changing just the shower or bathtub, or doing a tub-to-shower or shower-to-tub conversion. They also offer “accessible bathroom” options like walk-in tubs or showers, slip-resistant floors, grab-bars, and other safety features for people who want safety.
Rebath gives you free initial design consultation before you commit to hire them for upgrade or remodeling. For consultation purpose, a design expert visits, checks your bathroom, shows design ideas, and helps you choose styles, colors, and materials
Once you pick what you want, their team handles everything from removing old fixtures and finishes, to preparing the space, then installing new tubs/shower, walls, flooring, fixtures, lighting, vanities, and more.
Despite complete remodeling, many Re-Bath projects finish in just a few days so you don’t have to live without a usable bathroom for long.
Re-Bath uses a material called DuraBath for the walls around your tub or shower. It is waterproof material and water cannot leak through it. Because of their water resistance mold or mildew do not grow easily.
Installation Process
Each brand’s installation process is unique, affecting the time and labor involved.
Bath Planet
Bath Planet starts with a free consultation and design meeting. Then they measure your bathroom carefully. Once custom parts are ready, their team does the renovation so that you may get a new tub or shower (or tub-to-shower conversion) in as little as one day.
Because they avoid heavy demolition like tearing down walls or redoing major plumbing; the job is faster and creates less mess than a full rebuild. At the end, they do a final walk-through to check everything, ensuring it is watertight and clean.
Bath Fitter
Just like bath planet, Bath Fitter also begins with a free in-home consultation and measurement to custom fit their products to your bathroom. They manufacture custom acrylic tubs, showers, and wall panels based on your exact bathroom size.
Their installation is designed to go over your existing tub or shower. Therefore the installation process doesn’t need demolition or major plumbing work. In many cases, Bath Fitter can finish the installation in just one day.
Re-Bath
Like bath planet and Bath Fitter, Re-Bath also starts with a free design consultation, where they assess your bathroom, talk about style, and plan what needs to be changed.
Their renovation process involves a full bathroom makeover. Because the scope is larger, Re-Bath’s installations take days instead of hours or a single day. They use licensed, insured crews who handle all the work from demolition of old fixtures to installing new ones.
As Bath planet and bathe fitter have the same scope of work and almost similar services, we can say that they are competitors and have almost similar installation processes, too. But in case of Re-Bath, the scope of work is wider and involve more activities therefor it their installation process takes more time, demolition and even more cost
Cost Comparison: Finding the Right Price Point
Budget is often a key factor in choosing a bathroom remodeling service. Each brand’s costs differ based on the complexity of the project, the materials used, and the level of customization.
Bath Planet
Bath Planet’s website does not publish a fixed price list or “starting from” price that applies universally to all users because prices depend mainly on bathroom size, which features you choose (doors, finishes, accessories), possible plumbing work, and region.
To get the exact budget information for your remodel, you need to request a free in-home consultation/quote. During the initial consultation, cost is individually calculated by the visiting team.
But most of the testimonials and clients linked to bath planet say that total remodels including tub/shower conversions or replacements tend to cost roughly $6,000 to $17,000 on average.
Bath Fitter
Bath Fitter’s cost depends on your existing bathroom, what you choose, and what you need replaced as there’s no “one size fits all” price.
If you want to know exactly how much it will cost for your bathroom, you need to book their free consultation and get a personalized quote.
According to a rough estimate, many simple Bath Fitter remodels tend to fall around $3,000–$7,500, but final price can be lower or higher depending on a lot of factors like the size of your bathtub or shower area, the condition of your current tub or shower, whether you choose a tub liner, shower liner, or a full replacement, extra features you want, the wall design and materials you choose, plumbing changes, custom shapes or unusual layouts, your location etc.
Re-Bath
Just like the other two companies, Re-Bath has given no exact information about the cost at its website and like others they ask you to contact them and schedule their free in-home design consultation, explain whether you want tub/shower replacement, or full renovation, or something in between, and pick materials and finishes. Once you give them all information about your choices they check your bathroom size, plumbing, walls, floor and then they give you a custom quote that fits your situation.
But few testimonials and clients of the company say that for simpler updates like a tub/shower replacement or a basic liner, costs often start around US $5,000 and can go up to US $10,000. Full bathroom remodeling estimates between US $23,000 and US $30,000.
Materials and Quality
Each of these brands is known for using high-quality materials, though the type of material differs across companies.
Bath Planet
Bath Planet’s bathtubs, showers, and wall-surround systems are made of high-quality acrylic They claim that their bathtubs are made from ¼-inch acrylic, which is stronger than what many other competitors use.
Moreover, their acrylic is non-porous which means it does not absorb water so it’s resistant to mold, mildew, and staining. Bath Planet’s wall systems are “grout-free” which means that they come as single panels. Because the material is strong and well-built, Bath Planet claims their tubs and showers are “low maintenance” and they resist cracks, chips, fading, damage or wear over time.
Bath Fitter
Bath Fitter uses high-gloss acrylic for its bathtubs, shower bases, and wall/liner panels. Just like Bath Planet, their acrylic is non-porous and water resistant. The acrylic is also lightweight but strong, and Bath Fitter backs their products with a lifetime warranty, showing they trust the material’s durability.
Re-Bath
ReBath uses a material called DuraBath for their bath walls and surrounds. It is available either as solid-surface acrylic panels or natural-stone-look solid-surface panels depending on what you choose. These DuraBath panels are waterproof and grout free, too.
Rebath’s material selection is broader, given its focus on full remodels. They offer everything from ABS polymer to solid surfaces and even some tile options.
When we talk about overall quality of services, some customers report that the customer service from Rebath and Bath Planet is superior to that of Bath Fitter. Moreover Bath fitter relies more on Bath Fitter relies on prefabricated parts and offer comparatively less custom services therefore Rebath and Bath Planet are generally considered to offer higher quality products than Bath Fitter
Pros and Cons: Which Brand is Right for You?
Now let’s explore some pros and cons of each option:
- Bath Planet: Bath Planet is best for those who want a quick, efficient remodel at an affordable price. However, because they focus on surface replacements and conversions, they’re not ideal for those wanting a full remodel.
- Bath Fitter: Bath Fitter is perfect for homeowners who want a fresh look without the hassle of demolition. While limited to acrylic liners, Bath Fitter’s quality and customization options make it a popular choice.
- Rebath: Rebath is the ideal choice for those looking for a comprehensive remodel. Though it’s more expensive, the investment can be worthwhile for homeowners wanting a brand-new bathroom with lasting materials.
Making the Final Decision
In choosing between Bath Planet, Bath Fitter, and Rebath, consider your budget, the scope of your remodel, and your timeline. If you’re looking for a quick and affordable transformation, Bath Planet or Bath Fitter may be the way to go. However, if you want a complete remodel that reimagines your bathroom from top to bottom, Rebath offers comprehensive services to bring your vision to life. With this knowledge, you can confidently choose a remodeling service that best suits your needs and preferences.
FAQs about Bath Planet vs Bath Fitter vs Rebath
1. Which bathroom remodeling company is best: Bath Planet, Bath Fitter, or Re-Bath?
Deciding the best one out of these three depends on you, your budget, your remodeling requirement. For you the one that best aligns with your needs and budget is obviously best for you. But if you are looking for complete remodeling of your bathroom, Rebath is a better option. And if you want to upgrade the bathtub or shower in a day or two, bath fitter and bath planet will be good choices for you.
2. What is the main difference between Bath Planet, Bath Fitter, and Re-Bath?
The main difference is in their services. Rebath gives a full bathroom remodeling whereas Bath fitter and Bath Planet only provide upgradation. Moreover, .Bath Fitter has spent more years in the market as compared to bath planet, so it has more experience of dealing with upgrades. But overall Rebath and Bath Planet offer more customization and have comparatively better customer service. The Rebath offer their hardware and equipment in a variety of materials like DuraBath, ABS polymer and so on. Whereas Bath fitter and Bath planet mostly use acrylic bathtub showers and walls.
3. Is Bath Planet really a one-day remodel?
Yes, most Bath Planet projects can be done in one day because they don’t involve major demolition and plumbing work. They just measure your current bathtub or shower and take their dimensions to make a replica in terms of dimension by not in design and style so it exactly fits the current bath or shower. Moreover their major service is Bathtub to shower conversion and vise versa.
4. What does Bath Fitter actually install?
Bath Fitter begins the installation process with a free in-home consultation and measurement to custom fit their products to your bathroom. They manufacture custom acrylic tubs, showers, and wall panels based on your exact bathroom size.
Their installation is designed to go over your existing tub or shower. Therefore the installation process doesn’t need demolition or major plumbing work. In many cases, Bath Fitter can finish the installation in just one day.